The dichotomy that is Comcast customer service

Comcast is one of those companies on the leading edge of leveraging social media for delivering high levels of customer service.  In fact, I recently gave them praise for quickly helping me resolve a networking problem in my house entirely through Twitter.

Sometimes, however, even companies that understand customer service fall down when it comes to the basics, as can be seen by what is taking place in my small home town of Winthrop, Massachusetts.  On Thursday afternoon my father in-law lost TV reception in his house.  We called and, after navigating through the IVR system, reached a message stating that there were known problems in our area, stay tuned.  It is now Sunday night, no TV service.  This, in isolation, is not a big deal, however, as you start to dig in, this is a major failure by Comcast, a failure that I hope is addressed both in restitution to the customers affected and also in the processes and systems where failures have occurred.  Lets dig in:

  • My father in-law has called Comcast more than a dozen times and I have called for him as well.  Each time, people have no knowledge of the past calls, that his house was added to a broader ticket.  He has had his box reset, been told it is a broad problem, been told to wait.  No information on when this problem will be fixed.
  • The IVR system forces you down a path where you enter your phone # and, if you answer the prompts correctly, are always taken to the automated response that tells you to wait.  You must answer the questions incorrectly to reach a real person.
  • As my father in-law has chatted with neighbors he has learned that many of them are dealing with their own television outages.  Some of these failures have gone on for a week or longer, each of them waiting, calling multiple times a day, no resolution.
  • One of the times I called for my father in-law I had him added to a ticket covering multiple homes, being told that Winthrop was having a large outage, ongoing, no clear time for fixing.  If I wanted to call another department I could discuss a refund.  What?!?!?!  Comcast, you are failing to deliver service, failing to deliver answers, and failing to simply reach out and take care of those customers….  This is not acceptable.

Please understand, I have nothing against Comcast or its people.  However, these failures are indicative of a lack of process, poor system integration, and a misunderstanding of how to service your customers.  Comcast:

  • Please let me know how many customers in Winthrop are down and the total # of days they have been without service.
  • What is your plan for proactively solving the problem and “making things right” with these customers?
  • Lets sit down and discuss where your system or process failures are happening.  If handled properly we can work together to fix these problems.
  • I know you want to deliver great service.  The efforts of people like Frank Eliason show me that you’re on the right track.  Lets see if we can work to make failures like this a thing of the past.

John

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to TwitterAdd to TechnoratiAdd to Yahoo BuzzAdd to Newsvine

Advertisement

8 Responses to “The dichotomy that is Comcast customer service”

  1. Deborah Channing Says:

    That is a wonderful concept. I really believe it will work out to be a very crucial piece of information in the future for me.

  2. Mike Watson @Mikewat Says:

    Step 1. Collect underpants.
    Step 2…..
    Step 3. Profit!

    I r seriouz post. No really. Comcast is evolving from horrible, to now mediocre, to something better in the future. Your post should be a wake up call for comcast to enact the 2nd part of their customer service strategy.

    • John Moore Says:

      Thanks Mike, enjoyed your comments! :-)

  3. gregmeyer Says:

    John -

    Thanks for your post. I recently had an eventually positive interaction with @comcastcares that was triggered after I objected to content that Comcast was playing on the video feed for the OnDemand (they call it “the barker”). The initial contact was middling — the rep gave me incorrect information, and then two reps had trouble connecting the same complaint — but ultimately I got connected to Frank E., and appreciated the opportunity to share my comments directly with him.

    I think Comcast is trying — I also think that they are at the mercy of an organizational structure based in franchise operation and not yet a national org — and that they have a ways to go. @Comcastcares and publishing their email address is a long way towards a positive solution. When that system works for the average consumer I think they will have succeeded. Judging from your issue in Winthrop, the phone reps aren’t there yet.

    –Greg

    • John Moore Says:

      Thanks for weighing in Greg. It is difficult moving an organization as large as Comcast’s. It’s moving, just taking a very long time.

  4. Tim Says:

    Oh, the joys of being a Comcast customer…

    Several years ago, I signed up for HDTV/Internet from Comcast. After about 6 months, their computer decided that I had two cable modems and needed to return one of them. Even after several requests for documentation showing that I have the second cable modem, no documentation was sent (even thought they promised it on several occassions). I even visited the local comcast office several times to try to get this resolved, but all they could do was to tell me to call the Comcast 800 number… apparently all they can do is take monthly payments from people – they aren’t allowed to actually help customers.

    So after a year or so I moved to another apartment and cancelled my service, returning the modem I had – and I made sure to return it to the office and get a receipt for the return.

    But the Comcast computers still thought that I had another modem (different serial # from the one I returned). Several more phone calls, and all I ended up getting out of comcast was a bunch of bills for the ‘unreturned’ equipment.

    At one point I talked to someone and they corrected the system – and I got a statement show that I had overpaid by $6. But their computer system was too smart for itself and couple of months later I got another bill for the cable modem I never had…

    And three years later, I still get a bill for that modem every once in a while.

    Just so you know, every time I call, I have to start all over – it’s impossible to talk to the same person twice, and their ticketing system is completely useless because they person I’m talking to can never figure out how to pull up my past tickets, and somehow records of my previous phone calls never seem to stick to my account…

    I’ve completely given up on it. They are incompetent. Completely incompetent.

    I check my credit report every year, and they haven’t filed anything on it. The moment they do, I’m ready to file a protest and give them a mountain of paperwork to show that the debt is not legitimate.

    ….sigh….

    Why is it so difficult to get someone to fix this?

  5. Sahara Says:

    Hi John. I actually snickered when reading this. Recently I called Comcast 3 times within the same hour and received 3 different prices of a new combination movie channel promotion. In fact, each time I called, it increased $3-5.00. They had no record of my previous call (that had just occurred) and would not honor the price the previous customer service agent gave. Needless to say, I did NOT take part in the promo in the end.

    That’s just one of my many Comcast stories. And I believe they are common. I’ve been looking for a solution or alternate choice, but haven’t made a concrete decision yet.

    Thanks for posting this. :)

    • davednh Says:

      Comcast seems to be a great service as long as there is no outage and no change in pricing/packages. But, open up that door and look out! I have had both good and bad service recently (VoIP line is excellent but cableCARDs in my TiVo HD has been a horrible experience). Along the way I found out that not only can you rarely talk to the same person twice, you often get different answers from each of the people. These answers include what channels are included in a new digital package, what the specific monthly prices for my CableCARDS were going to be, whether I would be charged for an install visit and if so how much (there were three options here – $99, $29, and $0).
      My major beef with Comcast is that they are not keeping their own people up to speed with the (too) many options in pricing and packages which leads to people making up answers when they are not sure.
      My advice to all would be that if you are considering a TiVo HD and you have Comcast, don’t buy the TiVo HD (and I *love* TiVo, BTW). Just wait for Comcast to have the TiVo service embedded into their Cable boxes – it’s coming. CableCARDS are a *huge* waste of time. Comcast hates them, TiVo hates them, apparently only CableLabs likes them – maybe they and SA (Cisco now) should make CableCARDS more reliable (note: it took me 4 tech visits and 7 CableCARDS to get 2 that worked – then I had to make calls to fix the incorrect billing as an added value).
      …Sometimes Comcast does a very good job and they are getting better…but they should stick to VoIP and stop trying to put a cable box in front of every one of my TV sets.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.