If transparency is not demanded is it really needed?

I live in a small town, as I have mentioned before.  Like most cities and towns around the country, budgets are tight and public employees are facing the crisis as hard, if not harder, than the private sector.  Now, stay with me for a second as I am looking to make a point beyond the back-room politics that are taking place in one small town.

  • The teachers in town have not had a contract in two years, nor a raise.  The lack of contract is a big issue, the lack of raises in this economy is not.
  • To save the town money the teachers switched from one health insurance to another, saving the town approximately $700,000.
  • The Superintendent is one of the highest paid in the state of Massachusetts.  He, and now many of the Principals working for him, were just given raises by the School Committee.
  • The School Committee will only give the teachers a contract with a four year of 0% raises.
  • The School Committee and the Teachers are using a mediator in their attempt to reach a contract.  When asked about the school budget, the negotiator was informed that all questions must be received one week prior to the next meeting and only those questions will be discussed.

While I am personally annoyed by the petty politics in Winthrop, Massachusetts, and I feel that ethical lines are being crossed, lets step back for a second.  Voters, town citizens, are not up in arms shouting to learn more, to get to the bottom of issues.  Transparency, and other government 2.0 benefits, are not on the average citizen’s mind.  When citizens and local governments are not seeking change is there any problem afterall?

What do you think?  Is transparency really needed when no one is asking for it?

John

Add to FacebookAdd to DiggAdd to Del.icio.usAdd to StumbleuponAdd to RedditAdd to BlinklistAdd to TwitterAdd to TechnoratiAdd to Yahoo BuzzAdd to Newsvine

9 Responses to “If transparency is not demanded is it really needed?”

  1. Mike P Says:

    Just because people are not asking for something does not mean that they do not want it. Imagine if you were doing things ahead of the curve and before it being demanded. Do you not think that would bring about more happy audience, knowing what they need and taking action before they ask. Waiting too long to take action is where things seem to fall apart.

    Mike P | @mikepascucci

  2. Dan Bevarly Says:

    I agree w/ Elliot, but can state it much simpler: “Ignorance is bliss.”

    • John Moore Says:

      Ignorance is bliss as long as everyone shares in the ignorance. Miserable for those that know better. :-)

  3. Ari Herzog Says:

    I don’t know why you lump transparency and government 2.0 in the same sentence, when they are different animals. I’d go so far as argue “government 2.0″ needn’t necessarily involve the web at all, but a different way of thinking.

    As for whether something is needed if nobody asks for it, let me ask how you can prove a tree falls in the forest if nobody sees it fall.

  4. uberVU - social comments Says:

    Social comments and analytics for this post…

    This post was mentioned on Twitter by JohnFMoore: My latest, If transparency is not demanded is it really needed? http://bit.ly/cDLqKc #gov20 #localgovchat #journchat…

  5. Adriel Hampton Says:

    Needed, but will not happen if not demanded and followed up on during campaign season.

    • John Moore Says:

      Great points Adriel. I may be working sooner than expected to bring government 2.0 to Winthrop, not as an elected official but as a citizen. Time to put some of this to practice right here at home.

      John

  6. elliotross Says:

    I think part of your answer is a deeper question for citizens.

    Is this lack of interest just ignorance, or apathy

    Would transparency remove these?

    The flip side of course is that opacity is often a friend in politics

    So it gets fairly circular!
    Regards
    Elliot


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.